Souter Fell, near Mungrisdale in the north-eastern Lake District, is the site of one of the most frequently cited traditional ghost sightings in all of English folklore, and it earns that status precisely because of the unusual number of independent witnesses involved rather than because of any single dramatic account. The first report dates to Midsummer Eve 1735, when a servant of William Lancaster of Blakehills, about half a mile from the fell, described watching the east side of the summit covered by a marching army for over an hour continuously; disbelieved by his neighbours at the time, he was largely dismissed and the matter quietly dropped.
A second and far better attested sighting followed on Midsummer Eve, commonly dated 1745, when around twenty-six people, watching independently from different vantage points around the fell, reported seeing ranks of horsemen crossing the fell's summit ridge for as long as two and a half hours, moving steadily along a line of ground that later careful inspection showed to be too steep and broken for cavalry, or indeed any horse at all, to physically traverse.
After that second sighting, a deliberate watch was organised on the following Midsummer Eve, with witnesses positioned specifically to observe and record any recurrence of the phenomenon, and, by the traditional account passed down since, it duly reappeared exactly as before. The case drew the genuine interest of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Walter Scott and James Hogg among other major literary figures of the period, and it has been repeatedly discussed by both believers and sceptics in the centuries since. Suggested explanations range from atmospheric mirage effects, a form of Brocken spectre or Fata Morgana caused by unusual refraction over the fell's distinctive terrain, to mass suggestion following the widely discussed first report, though no explanation has ever been definitively established to everyone's satisfaction. Its combination of multiple named, contemporary witnesses and a physically impossible route makes it one of the stronger traditional cases in the whole of English ghost-lore, whatever the underlying cause ultimately proves to be.
Comments